Rating: * * *
Shiny Stars: Gary Oldman, Emma Thompson, David Thewlis
Directed by: Alfonso Cuaron
Haiku Synopsis:
Hermione hold hands with Ron
while Harry looks on
there are dark circles under his eyes
With the director of
Y Tu Mama Tabien, you'd think that there would be some hot teenage love scenes. But alas, what we have is a mildly entertaining hodge podge of horror movie cliches, minus the traditional teenage victims caught in the throes of sex. After all, they are all virgins.
For purists, the movie departs from the previous 2 installments by not adhering as closely to the text. Now I will say that
The Prisoner of Azkaban was the first Harry Potter book I read so many years ago, and I cannot recall any specific details. I will rely upon WTF who says some plot points and details were changed for the movie.
This could be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on whether you're a text fundamentalist or a film enthusiast. Certainly, a very difficult question to answer, because basically, you have two types of media. A reader will always have grander movie in their mind than the viewer of a film. And perhaps this is what will ulitmately kill the franchise, as J.K. Rowling novel installments are getting more and more convoluted.
Filming the novels exposes the flaws of the original text and really reminds us that these novels are really children's novels. The cliches appear bigger than life when we see the werewolf attack in the moonlight or the dog run tear through the moor (um i think it's a moor). Though the novels themselves are rather unoriginal, this fact doesn't diminish the pleasure one gets from reading them. They are written nicely and really appeals to the nostalgia of childhood. But for a good movie in its own rights, this doesn't do.
The novelty has worn off, the charm of the principal leads have aged. What's left is a pleasant trip through the same castle, a few exciting bits of magic, a darker ride through the various plotlines and a less funny script. Ron looks especially old, Harry's voice has changed and Herminone.. well.. her hair is a lot neater. Perhaps she switched to Vidal Sassoon from baby shampoo.
Or you can say this is a very deep movie, with the werewolf and animagus themes symbolizing the changes in the kids from mere pre-teens to teenagers. The drop in Harry's voice is mirrored by the darkness of the movie. The manipulation of time representing one of the worse things about being a teen: that time goes by far too slowly and you can't wait to grow up... but step over that 18 years and you realize your childhood slipped you by.
Or not. It's just a kid's movie. And they're still virgins... and harry will be a hot boy when he grows up.